MR GHAMIDI SHOW ON PUKHTUN TRIBAL PRACTISES AND MY RESPONSE

Image

It was fascinating and disappointing at the same time to see Mr Ghamidi a religious scholar of his calibre trying to answer a political question in his show on Samaa Pakistan TV channel. Mr Ghamidi tried to explain Taliban beheading of 23 Frontier corp soldiers  in the view of tribal culture and its people as primitive and savages, where a 7 years old boy will have no hesitation of beheading another human being .

Mr Ghamidi tried in his show to explain tribal societies which according to him all over the world are violence prone barbaric, hence throat cutting or beheading is a  part of the violence rituals practised by these  tribal humanoids.

He also condemned the Pakistan Govt for keeping Pakistan   tribal areas in political, social isolation resulting in society where violence is synonymous with tribal pukhtun culture and is a norm.

Mr Ghamidi well intentioned explanation of pukhtun tribal culture although goes all politically wrong. And this is I guess  what happen if a religious leader is asked to explain a political phenomena with half-baked truth dished out to progressive Muslim all over Pakistan. Or maybe it was an attempt to deflect the blame from the source which lies somewhere in the heart of Pakistan.

Mr Ghamidi completely forgot in his  analysis while  responding to one question by the anchor of the show  and  that was “ how can people behead and kill each other in such manner”  Mr Ghamidi justified it that this is part of the tribal culture  and has been happening in all  primitive societies , but nobody conveniently  remembers on the show  the fact that those FC beheaded soldiers who were fighting for the state sovereignty against those very same  forces , were also from the same tribal culture which Mr Ghamidi justifies and condemns in the same tone.

The ‘Frontier Corps (FC) are a Federal paramilitary force manned mostly by people from the tribal areas, lest we forget  the same area which Mr  Ghamidi and the callers equated with violence and beheading .

Jirga which compromises a major component of tribal justice system, does it condone beheading or prescribe it as form of punishment for any criminal offender?  No it does not.  At least I have not come across it. I would happily hear from anyone who has seen beheading as official practise of the tribal society. Hundreds of tribal elders were also brutally killed and humiliated in Waziristan, Bajaur, Orakzai and Mohmand agencies, the elders with white beards (speen geeray) were the revered and respected part of the tribal society. . ? Mosques funeral schools ,children women none were spared . Was this a part of tribal culture too?

A caller in the programme calls the whole society of tribal as mercenaries and paid killers who has been doing killing for years. I think the people sitting and shaping this narrative completely forgo the details, that there are at least 3 million people sitting displaced from their homes as IDPs. People who do not wish to be part of that violence, people who are tired of gunpowder, killings and want to have security of lives for themselves and their families. Mr Ghamidi and the anchor did not take the trouble to talk or dissuade the caller that the whole population and society cannot be in one breath declared as mercenaries.

When the whole society and area was being militarised under the guise of Islamic jihad of 1979, then no voices were heard by calling people from FATA as mercenaries, rather at that time, they were called Nobel savages ready to fight Pakistan and Americanised jihad in Afghanistan .Qabil brothers and children provided or had no choice but to provide human fodder to the jihad on which whole of Pakistan thumped its chest   and happily lead the Muslim ulema.  An analysis of the economic indicators of tribal areas places them in the fourth world. FATA which comprises of seven political agencies along with FR areas   remains Pakistan   poorest region, with 3.1 million population which according to unofficial estimate has reached over seven million. Nearly 66 % of the population lives below the poverty line.  How did Afghan jihad mercenaries benefited from being the Nobel jihadi. Maybe by letting state establish 1000 debandi madrasah’s which preached jihad and they continued to play the role of jihadi for the state and establishment.

How do one justify the urban violence in Karachi Pakistan’s largest city, which generates around 70 per cent of national GDP and has been declared the mega violent city in the world according to one major US publication, citing a murder rate of 12.3 per 100,000 residents 25 per cent higher than any other major cities in the world?  If violence and beheading is tribal society phenomena then Karachi experienced its deadliest year on record in 2013, with 2,700 casualties, mostly in targeted attacks and we also heard the concept of body bags, which possibly resulted in 40per cent of businesses fleeing the city to avoid growing extortion rackets. However all provincial capitals as well as the national capital suffer from similar problems and threats. So is violence only centric to tribal pukhtun culture?   Or  are we ready to condemn and berate the culture of people residing in one of the biggest metropolitan city of Pakistan too.

Taliban which is primarily now only equated with pukhtun and tribal ethnicity, but it is the Punjabi Taliban which drives extremism in the rest of Pakistan and has its strong roots in Punjab. There are approximately 150,000 insurgents belonging to jihadi and fundamentalists organisation active in Punjab province, carrying out their activities in the rest of Pakistan.   Quetta Peshawar, Karachi is a major target of violent sectarian groups such as the Lashkar-e-Jhangvi (LeJ), which has its home base in Punjab .The Sunni extremist and southern Punjab-based Lashkar-Jhangvi (LeJ), which was instrumental in the TTP’s formation (now equated with pukhtun and tribal only), continues to be a major player in sectarian violence and minority persecution all over the country.However we chose not to talk about that aspect of violence ,where Ahmadi graves are dug up and Shia are shot on point blank in the civilised cities of Pakistan .

Pakistan army operation in tribal belt  previous and current acknowledges the presence of foreign militant like Uzbek, Chechen and mostly Arab  since more than 15,000 Arabs, Uzbek and Chechen were repatriated to and settled in FATA to fight holy war against the Soviets. So can we assume safely  that instead of being a pukhtun tribal culture, beheading is more of Arab culture and part of their pre Islam and post Islam war ethos? Wasn’t Imam Hussein (ra) head carried on an arch and paraded in the city of Kufa?

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “MR GHAMIDI SHOW ON PUKHTUN TRIBAL PRACTISES AND MY RESPONSE

  1. I think Ghamidi is very right in saying what he said and I would like to support his view.
    The version of Islam present in the tribal areas is a mix of Pushtun rigid cultural practices, where a woman is to be killed if she chooses to marry with her own will(don’t dare deny this, I’ve personally witnessed many such incidents where educated Pashtuns carried out this practice), otherwise the family of the woman will remain in eternal shame of tolerating a beghairat aurat.

    The violence present in Pukhtun culture is indeed conducive to what we’re seeing these days in the form of TTP, with most pashtuns supporting the actions of Taliban. Pashtuns are long known for not educating their women so are the taliban. Domestic violence is also very common in Pashtun culture, which lead the taliban to flog women in public and later attack Malala.

    You don’t want to open your eyes to the fact but this is the truth, its the unislamic, inhuman and violent practices of intolerance in Pushtun culture which is acting like dry wood for the already blazing fire of extremism.

    The violence in Karachi is also because of Pashtuns.
    They introduced the weapons in Karachi, in fact they had the weapons even in the 60s when most of the other races could even imagine seeing one, let alone owning.

    Pashtuns were involved in the 4th Jan 1965 massacre of Karachi, under the leadership of Gohar Ayub, hundreds of innocents were killed that day, just for supporting Fatima Jinnah instead of Ayub Khan. Other races have now taken arms to resist against this firouniat.

    How dare you justify a culture where non-pakhtuns are seen as lesser human beings?
    During the time when this region was “Ilaqa Ghair”, a criminal/murderer would never find justice if he had committed the crime elsewhere in Pakistan and fled to ilaqa ghair.

    Please don’t justify the violence in your culture and make an effort to reduce the level of racism and violence that you have, because this will only demolish and disintegrate your race even further.

    You, just like the rest of Pakistan are reaping what you’ve sown. Talibans are nothing but a mutated form of Pashtun culture.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s